Skip to content
Burgas · PlovdivMon–Fri 9:00–17:30 (EET)

Pensioner's long-term residence permit in Bulgaria: refusals

Why are pensioners denied residence in Bulgaria despite having sufficient funds? We explain legal requirements, reasons for refusal and appeal options.

A long-term residence permit in Bulgaria for a pensioner: why refusals happen when the pension is lower than the Bulgarian one

The “pensioner with sufficient means” ground is one of the most attractive ways to obtain residence in Bulgaria. It allows foreign nationals entitled to a pension to move to the country without having to start a business, take up employment or make investments.

However, over the past few years foreign pensioners have been facing a serious problem: the Bulgarian migration authorities refuse to issue a long-term residence permit if the amount of the foreign pension is lower than the minimum pension set in Bulgaria.

This problem is particularly relevant for citizens of Ukraine and other countries where pension payments are significantly lower than the Bulgarian ones.

This raises a legitimate question: why does a pensioner who has met the mandatory financial means requirement and has placed in a Bulgarian bank account a sum equivalent to 12 minimum Bulgarian pensions still risk being refused?

We will address these questions, and also look at the situation where a pensioner plans to move to Bulgaria together with a spouse who does not yet receive a pension.

1. What does the “pensioner with sufficient means” ground mean?

The right to obtain a long-term residence permit is provided for in Art. 24, para. 1, item 10 of the Law on Foreigners in the Republic of Bulgaria (ZChRB).

This ground applies to foreign nationals who have acquired the right to a pension in Bulgaria, in their country of origin or in another country and who have sufficient means to support themselves.

At the same time, Bulgarian legislation does not require that the pension be paid specifically by Bulgaria.

But two conditions must be distinguished:

First — the existence of a right to a pension. The applicant must confirm that he or she has indeed acquired pension rights in accordance with the legislation of the relevant country.

Second — financial means. The pensioner must confirm that he or she has the funds required to live in Bulgaria.

In practice, obtaining a pensioner’s long-term residence permit requires having in a Bulgarian bank account a sum equivalent to at least 12 minimum Bulgarian pensions.

This is a mandatory financial requirement that must be arranged before filing the documents.

But even meeting this requirement does not always protect a pensioner from a refusal.

2. Why do refusals occur if the money is already in the account?

Let us look at a common situation.

A citizen of Ukraine receives a pension of 250 euros per month. He plans to move to Bulgaria and opens an account with a Bulgarian bank in advance.

The account holds the required amount, corresponding to 12 minimum Bulgarian pensions.

In this way, the pensioner confirms that he has the financial means for the period of residence.

However, when reviewing the application, the migration authority notes that his monthly pension is lower than the minimum Bulgarian pension.

As a result, there is a risk of refusal.

This is where the main problem lies: the applicant has met the requirement to have financial means, but the amount of the pension payment itself becomes an additional obstacle.

To what extent does this comply with the legislation?

3. Is a refusal based on a small foreign pension lawful?

Article 24, para. 1, item 10 of the ZChRB provides for two main conditions: the existence of an acquired right to a pension and sufficient means to support oneself.

At the same time, the provision itself does not establish a direct requirement that a foreign pension must necessarily be equal to the minimum Bulgarian pension.

At the same time, Art. 24, para. 2 of the ZChRB sets out general requirements for the financial means of foreigners.

It is precisely the relationship between these provisions that is of fundamental importance.

The right to a pension and the amount of funds required to support oneself are different legal circumstances.

If the pensioner has confirmed that the required funds are held in a Bulgarian bank account, the question arises: is the migration authority entitled to refuse solely because the monthly pension is lower than the Bulgarian one?

In our view, such a refusal should not be regarded as automatically lawful.

The administrative authority is obliged to assess all applicable requirements of the law, the evidence submitted and the applicant’s specific circumstances.

However, it cannot be claimed that having the required amount in a bank account guarantees that a long-term residence permit will be granted.

Other circumstances may also be assessed when reviewing an application, including the nature and sufficiency of the financial means.

The lawfulness of a refusal therefore has to be analysed on a case-by-case basis.

4. What does Bulgarian case law say?

The question of financial means of foreign pensioners has been considered by the administrative courts of Bulgaria.

Case law includes instances where refusals were annulled because the court found an incorrect application of substantive law or an insufficient assessment of the applicant’s circumstances.

At the same time, it must be understood that a court ruling in one case does not automatically render all similar refusals unlawful.

The court reviews the specific administrative act, the grounds on which it was issued and the evidence submitted by the applicant.

The key legal question is whether the migration authority is entitled, in effect, to impose an additional requirement as to the amount of a foreign pension if the applicant has already confirmed the required financial means.

The answer depends on the applicable legal provisions, the content of the refusal and the circumstances of the particular case.

This is why, upon receiving a refusal, it is important not to rely on the verbal explanations of migration service officers, but to analyse the official written decision.

5. What should a pensioner do if a long-term residence permit is refused?

First of all, it is necessary to determine at which stage the refusal was issued.

It may be a refusal to issue a type D visa, or a refusal to grant or extend a residence permit within Bulgaria itself.

The appeal procedure differs in these situations.

If the refusal relates to an insufficient amount of foreign pension, it is necessary to establish:

  • Which specific provision of the law the administrative authority relies on.
  • Whether the presence of the required financial means in an account with a Bulgarian bank was taken into account.
  • Whether all circumstances and the evidence submitted were examined.
  • Whether there are legal grounds for appealing the decision.

Depending on the situation, an administrative or a judicial appeal is possible.

It is important to observe the deadlines: for many administrative refusals the general time limit for a judicial appeal is 14 days from notification, but the applicable rules must be checked against the specific decision.

Sometimes it makes sense to remedy the shortcomings identified and submit the documents again. In other cases the applicant’s rights must be defended by lodging an appeal.

The choice of strategy depends on the reasons for the refusal and on the documents of the particular pensioner.

6. How is a long-term residence permit arranged for a pensioner with sufficient means?

Stage one — obtaining a type D visa

Third-country nationals who require a type D visa submit their initial application through a Bulgarian diplomatic or consular mission.

At this stage, the existence of a lawful ground for long-term residence and compliance with the established requirements are checked.

Particular attention is paid to confirming pensioner status and sufficient financial means.

Following a positive decision, the applicant receives a type D visa allowing entry into Bulgaria to complete the residence formalities.

Stage two — obtaining the long-term residence permit in Bulgaria

After entering on a type D visa, the pensioner applies to the competent unit of the Migration Directorate of the Bulgarian Ministry of the Interior.

The migration service reviews the application independently and verifies compliance with the requirements of the law.

Even after a positive decision by the consulate, additional questions may arise when the migration authority reviews the application.

For this reason, proper preparation of the entire procedure matters even before the initial visa application.

7. A practical example: a pensioner relocating with a spouse who does not yet receive a pension

Consider the following situation.

Alexander is a Ukrainian citizen, receives a pension and plans to relocate to Bulgaria together with his wife Elena.

Elena has not yet reached retirement age and does not receive any pension payments.

The couple have sufficient funds for the relocation and for living in the country.

But it is not possible to obtain a long-term residence permit for both of them on the same pension ground.

Procedure No. 1 — obtaining a long-term residence permit for Alexander

Alexander applies in his own right on the ground of “financially secure pensioner”.

He goes through the procedure for obtaining a type D visa and then for obtaining a long-term residence permit.

If his pension is lower than the minimum Bulgarian pension, the possible risks of refusal must be assessed in advance, despite the presence of the required financial means.

Procedure No. 2 — obtaining a long-term residence permit for Elena

Since Elena is not a pensioner, her husband’s pension ground does not automatically extend to her.

For the spouse, the family reunification procedure provided for by Bulgarian migration law may apply.

In doing so, it is necessary to take into account Alexander’s status, the family reunification requirements and the order in which the applications are filed.

Thus, the relocation of one family involves two separate but legally connected procedures.

If this specific feature is not taken into account in advance, the spouses may face delays and the need to change their original relocation plan.

8. Why is it important to assess the risks before submitting documents?

At first glance, obtaining a long-term residence permit on pension grounds looks like a fairly simple procedure.

However, having a pension and the required amount in a bank account does not yet mean that the decision will necessarily be positive.

Particular care should be taken with the application if:

  • The foreign pension is lower than the minimum Bulgarian pension.
  • The pensioner plans to relocate together with a spouse who does not yet receive a pension.
  • A type D visa or a long-term residence permit has previously been refused.
  • There are circumstances requiring additional legal analysis.

In such situations, it is important not merely to prepare the documents, but to identify the possible grounds for refusal in advance and to choose the correct sequence of actions.

Conclusion

The ground of “financially secure pensioner” remains one of the attractive ways to obtain a long-term residence permit in Bulgaria.

However, the practice of refusals to pensioners receiving small foreign pensions shows that even meeting the mandatory requirement of financial means does not always guarantee a positive decision.

The amount of a foreign pension and the availability of sufficient funds to live on are two different circumstances that must be assessed correctly from the point of view of the law.

If a pensioner was refused solely because of a small pension, despite having the required means, the lawfulness of such a decision deserves separate analysis.

And if the relocation is planned together with a spouse who does not yet receive a pension, the legal ground for each family member must be determined in advance.

Planning to relocate to Bulgaria in retirement?

Bulgarian Expert provides advisory and practical assistance in obtaining a long-term residence permit on pension grounds.

We analyse the applicant’s financial situation, assess migration risks, support the processing of the type D visa and the residence permit, and also help organise the relocation of family members.

If your pension is lower than the minimum Bulgarian pension or you have already received a refusal, we recommend seeking an individual consultation before submitting documents again.

Bulgarian Expert — professional support for your relocation to Bulgaria.

Website: https://bulgarianexpert.com 

Telegram: https://t.me/bulgariaexpert 

Instagram: @bulgarianexpert

Need help?

Did not find the answer here? Write to us — we will look at your case and tell you what comes next.

Mon–Fri 9:00–17:30 (EET)

Message us

Ask a question

Let us look at your case

This article describes the general procedure. Your situation almost always has specifics — tell us about it and we will point out the shortest route.

Book a consultation

Send a request

We will reply within one business day and propose a route suited to your situation.